The Mystery of Her – a Book Review

The Mystery of Her by Patricia CatacalosTitle: The Mystery of Her by Patricia Catacalos

Genre: Currently #2164 on Amazon Best Sellers Rank in Kindle Store, Kindle eBooks, Mystery, Thriller & Suspense, Mystery, Historical

Publisher: Amazon Digital Services, LLC

Publication Date: May 2016

Source: Submitted by author for review

Title and Cover: The Mystery of Her – Cover hints at era

Lady Kiera Everett is pretty darned sure her father was murdered and how it could have been viewed as anything else, even in London in 1888, is beyond me given the nature of the manner in the first of the Zane Brothers Detective Series, “The Mystery of Her” by Patricia Catacalos. I’m a fan of historical fiction, particularly mysteries, and this was not my first rodeo, so perhaps my expectations were a bit high.

The author paints London in all it’s disease-ridden, dark and dank environment, where it would seem the street urchins outnumber the rats. It is a nasty time in history and not unexpected then that coinciding with the Lady’s quandary; the city is being terrorized by not one, but two serial killers in the slums of Whitechapel. She seeks the help of the Zane Brothers Detective Agency as the police have written off the death of her father as age and illness. Lady Everett has ascertained that hers is not the first loved one to die at the hands of the attending nurse and it doesn’t take too long before the bros realize she must be right.

In the meantime, she has been introduced to protagonist Zachary Zane, the oldest of three brothers with whom she has contracted the case under the proviso she is allowed to participate. WELL! Absolutely unheard of! She being a budding spinster and he any spinster’s dream catch are a given in the romance department.

I have to say that Ms. Catacalos certainly weaved a grim picture of London; you could smell the urine; see the rats and the garbage. I wanted to RUN, not walk, and wash my hands after her descriptions. The two younger brothers, Noah and Evan, go about the detecting business while Zachary schemes to make the Lady his wife. (Hmm, I think there’s an old joke there somewhere.) He is harboring a deep, dark secret but it soon becomes apparent that the Lady will be able to dispel the darker side and restore the lighter. Both he and his lady are fleshed out very well, the brothers not so much though they can be amusing. The antagonist never really becomes a viable character.

The dialogue can be a bit stilted at times, but it should be noted that the author has written with what might be late 1888 English sensibilities, vocabulary, and materials, as well as given the street urchins an Irish-cockney brogue. However, without giving away too much detail, the method of the murders of the rich but sickly men was really pushing the disbelief button (and I do not believe injections were commonly used at this time eliminating that as a possible method). If you can swallow that (and I’d seriously doubt it), then you might have a problem with the level of edit errors, the latter of which can easily be remedied. Also easily remedied is the over-abundance of the descriptively used words “angled” and “mimed.” (Mercy!)

Still, the book launches a promising series, a quick read, some gorge-producing scenes of late 19th Century London and a whirlwind Victorian romance (if you’re into that sort of thing). This book was provided by the author in exchange for a review. You might enjoy this as a cozy mystery summer read.3.5 of five stars

Rosepoint Publishing:  Three and one-half of Five Stars

Patricia Catacalos, authorThe Author: Patricia Catacalos has written a number of books crossing genres from paranormal to mystery, romance, and several novellas. She graduated from Seton Hill University and holds an MA in Theatre from the University of Denver. While she was still single, she acted in and directed productions in the Philadelphia area. Later, finding sales stifled her creative spirit, she began writing historical romances. She is married to a man of Greek heritage and they live in New Jersey when they are not traveling to both Greece and England. ©2017 Virginia Williams I Love Likes and Comments--Please Share!

Author: Rosepoint Publishing

I am the granddaughter of Patrick John "Stanley McShane" Rose whose books including "Cocos Island Treasure" I've recently published. My time is now spent in reading, reviewing, and writing bookish articles. I'm looking forward to sharing this social media odyssey with you!

I love comments, ideas, and sharing. I will respond to you shortly!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


Short story blogger - I hope you read

Emma's Writing Things

A place to share the things that I write

An Amyzing Journey

Tips, tricks, & funny stories about adventuring & mental health


memories and musings

Scribbles 'n Bits

Original poetry, short stories, and other bits



Let's talk

Vibe alone for a while

Barbara Crane Navarro

Rainforest Art Project - Pas de Cartier !

RealStuff by RealMe

Before, After, Then, Now and NEVER!

Islamic Dua and Wazifa For Love back and Solve All problems

Love problem Solution in just 2 Days: Lost love back, ex love back, ex husband back, ex boyfriend and other all love problem Solution. Call and Whatsapp +91 9571300113

Poetic reflections

Poetry and expression of ideas

Julia's Bookshelves

Book Reviews, Reccomendations, & Travel

Book Reviews, Tags, Vlogs, & More.


I read, rant and write ;)



Beneath The Bones

seeking inspiration

Learning Thursdays

It is hard to fail, but worse to have never tried - Abraham Lincoln


Becoming Unstuck



Bhuvana Chakra

The Power of Living God Ministries

The Wild Coach

You are an important nexus of energy


Blog do jornalista e professor Solon Saldanha

Happiness for a moment with you....

I'm glad I learned to express my thoughts clearly and everyone loves to read them. Sometimes it takes a lot of thinking power to think about the surroundings. Someone who likes it, someone who enjoys it, appreciates that he is writing very well. Reading and commenting on the post I wrote would give me a lot of bullshit and I would get new ideas to write new ones. I'm really glad I got your response.

Brian Cook's Blog

When the gods wish to punish us they answer our prayers. - Oscar Wilde

Writing Roses

Welcome to the Roses


I'm a Doctor with so many random thoughts, so I decided to blog.

Scott Clark | Teaching, Writing, Research

Portal to primary school blogs, research and resources | Middle Years/Young Adult story writing


a medical education website

Endless dreams and boundless imaginations!

We only live once. Hence, let's not stop dreaming


book reviews

Competitive World

Your Competitive Exam Companion

News from Ibonoco

Moments de vie, fragments de textes et quelques notes...

World Of Dreams Poetry

Universe Of Verse

Foster Your Writing

Write Like You Know What You're Doing

A Lifetime of Joy

You are never too old to set another goal or to dream a new dream ~C.S. Lewis


Author of Paranormal Suspense


Food, Road Trips & Notes from the Non-Profit Underground

%d bloggers like this: