An Eye For An Eye – a Book Review

An Eye For An Eye by Caroline FardigTitle: An Eye For An Eye (an Ellie Mathews Novel book #2) by Caroline Fardig

Genre: Currently #2077 on Amazon Best Sellers Rank in Kindle eBooks, Mystery, Thriller & Suspense, Mystery, Police Procedurals

Publisher: Amazon Digital Services LLC

Publication Date: To be released January 23, 2018 – Happy Publication Day!

Source: Publisher and NetGalley

Title and Cover: An Eye For An Eye – Cover depicts scene from book

Ellie Matthews switched to teaching at her local college after leaving her criminalist position with former partner Detective Nick Baxter. Ellie carries a lot of baggage and prefers the quiet, quasi-anonymous position of the college professor. Then one of her sister’s college friends goes missing and she finds herself thrust right back into the fray. This is the second in the series.

The opening chapter grabs your attention and proceeds from there, turning the pages. The body of the missing woman is found staged, posed, and left with negligible evidence, but before Ellie can really get into the science of her young friend, her expertise in forensics and crime scene investigation puts her center stage with the discovery of the body of another young woman. She is good at divorcing her emotions to separate out facts and whether or not she wants to pair with Det. Baxter again, finds herself doing so.

Then the first twist happens and it’s a douzy. Rachel, Ellie’s younger sister goes missing, and when they get a message regarding the demands, it’s one no one saw coming. Well-crafted plot delves into the science of forensics so it’s as fascinating as the story it weaves around. Explanation for procedures is handled as part of the investigation and the story never slows. The author avoids repeating theories over and over, but delves into many new possible scenarios. Sheriff Jayne Walsh is deeply involved since she is the aunt of the second victim, Jenna. The Feds are called in and, while everyone groans, takes over the investigation and divvies up responsibilities to appropriate team members and the race is on to find Ellie’s sister, Rachel.

The perp gives Ellie 72 hours to find his own mother’s killer, but Ellie apparently has another fight on her hands besides time. She and her erstwhile partner battle out their interviews and each other. Ellie is well fleshed, though it’s obvious has demons she has yet to conquer and Baxter brings her up short on the worst of them. She can be sharp and cryptic. It’s clear that Det. Baxter has feelings for her and he is well developed to the point of being sympathetic. Peripheral characters round out a good cast.

Interesting psychological study of the product of a desperately unhappy family situation turned deadly. Not the first female protagonist left with childhood trauma yet to be resolved. Dialogue is natural, though Ellie becomes unbecoming more than once and is difficult to empathize with (notwithstanding the deadly situation and time constraints). The climax satisfactorily closes the book though rather abruptly. Since we learned who was the main antagonist, it was a matter of finding him (and Ellie’s sister). I’d speculated the mother’s killer and was right, but not happy how that ended. (However, how else?)  The book leaves room for both the protagonist and Baxter to readdress each other and their relationship.

I downloaded this novel from the author and NetGalley and greatly appreciated the opportunity to read and review. Recommended for anyone who enjoys police procedurals, forensic studies, criminal minds, mystery, and thriller and suspense.

Rosepoint Publishing:  Four point five of Five Stars 4.5 of five stars

Caroline Fardig - authorThe Author: (From Amazon Author page) CAROLINE FARDIG is the USA TODAY BESTSELLING AUTHOR of the Java Jive Mysteries series and the Lizzie Hart Mysteries series. Fardig’s BAD MEDICINE was named one of the “Best Books of 2015” by Suspense Magazine. She worked as a schoolteacher, church organist, insurance agent, funeral parlor associate, and stay-at-home mom before she realized that she wanted to be a writer when she grew up. Born and raised in a small town in Indiana, Fardig still lives in that same town with an understanding husband, two sweet kids, two energetic dogs, and one malevolent cat. ©2018 V Williams  I Love Likes and Comments--Please Share!

Author: Rosepoint Publishing

I am the granddaughter of Patrick John "Stanley McShane" Rose whose books including "Cocos Island Treasure" I've recently published. My time is now spent in reading, reviewing, and writing bookish articles. I'm looking forward to sharing this social media odyssey with you!

2 thoughts on “An Eye For An Eye – a Book Review”

I love comments, ideas, and sharing. I will respond to you shortly!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Learning with Life

Poems, quotes, learning, feelings, introspect, experience as well as discovering..

Premier Tech Studios

You press Digital, We Do The Rest


Truth to Light

Reading with My Eyes

lots of tales from the spine, your place for book reviews of all kinds

Oma's Minute

The heart and thoughts of man is broad. I share reasonings that alot of people out there needs to hear and hopefully adds value to their world***

beauty care products

I am a blogger of beauty care products


Short story blogger - I hope you read

Emma's Writing Things

A place to share the things that I write

An Amyzing Journey

Tips, tricks, & funny stories about adventuring & mental health


memories and musings

Scribbles 'n Bits

Original poetry, short stories, and other bits.



Let's talk

Vibe alone for a while

Barbara Crane Navarro

Rainforest Art Project - Pas de Cartier !

RealStuff by RealMe

Before, After, Then, Now and NEVER!

Islamic Dua and Wazifa For Love back and Solve All problems

Love problem Solution in just 2 Days: Lost love back, ex love back, ex husband back, ex boyfriend and other all love problem Solution. Call and Whatsapp +91 9571300113

Poetic reflections

Poetry and expression of ideas

Julia's Bookshelves

Book Reviews, Reccomendations, & Travel

Book Reviews, Tags, Vlogs, & More.


I read, rant and write ;)



Beneath The Bones

seeking inspiration

Learning Thursdays

It is hard to fail, but worse to have never tried - Abraham Lincoln


Becoming Unstuck



Bhuvana Chakra

The Power of Living God Ministries

The Wild Coach

You are an important nexus of energy


Blog do jornalista e professor Solon Saldanha

Happiness for a moment with you....

I'm glad I learned to express my thoughts clearly and everyone loves to read them. Sometimes it takes a lot of thinking power to think about the surroundings. Someone who likes it, someone who enjoys it, appreciates that he is writing very well. Reading and commenting on the post I wrote would give me a lot of bullshit and I would get new ideas to write new ones. I'm really glad I got your response.

Brian Cook's Blog

When the gods wish to punish us they answer our prayers. - Oscar Wilde

Writing Roses

Welcome to the Roses


I'm a Doctor with so many random thoughts, so I decided to blog.

Scott Clark | Teaching, Writing, Research

Portal to primary school blogs, research and resources | Middle Years/Young Adult story writing


a medical education website

Endless dreams and boundless imaginations!

We only live once. Hence, let's not stop dreaming


book reviews

Competitive World

Your Competitive Exam Companion

%d bloggers like this: