Editors’ pick Best Literature & Fiction
Nominee for Readers’ Favorite Fiction (2014)
Another one I would not have chosen on my own. I love the way this book club is introducing me to good contemporary literature with multi-layered characters in unusual and unique settings. This one on fictional Alice Island, which is a ferry ride from Maine. A movie followed in 2022 by the same name and filmed on Cape Cod.
The loss of his wife has left A J Fikry in a spiraling downward trajectory to ruination. He owns a bookstore, which he now detests, is losing money, doesn’t eat properly or at all, and drinks to excess. He rejects the publisher’s sales rep and suffers the loss of a rare book apparently stolen that he’d counted on.
Then someone leaves a two-year-old in his store with a note begging him to take care of her.
I had a difficult time with this audiobook. Not because I couldn’t find the beauty in the prose or the lessons it serves, but I found it profoundly emotional sometimes to the point of being depressing. Nor did I feel the ending made it all okay. Yes, I understood the character’s rationale better, but it didn’t make it a happy ever after.
I found a deeper investment in the precocious child, the policeman, and Ismay, and wasn’t thrilled with the direction turned for A J. The twist did catch me by surprise, but, again, only seemed to me to be another sad point in the well-plotted novel.
Many thanks to our local well-stocked library for providing me with the opportunity to listen to and review this audiobook. The thoughts expressed here are my own as well as my interpretation of the consensus of the book club participants.
The publisher provides specific questions for discussion at the book club, ably kept on topic by the facilitator.
Discussions by the ladies found that most were delighted with the book and cited the short length as a positive. They thought the choice of the bookstore an excellent one made by the mother for a number of reasons. They enjoyed the character of the sales rep, Amelia Loman, while I thought it didn’t particularly sound like an obvious counterpart. The book club ladies were in agreement about the way the character of Ismay is written and got into a lively discussion when the twist is revealed. And…there again, they thought it was a satisfactory ending while I was left with what I thought was an unfulfilling conclusion.
It should be noted that this novel was also picked up as a major motion picture in 2022, starring Lucy Hale and Kunal Nayyar, and is now showing on Netflix. I was surprised by how much the movie borrowed from the book, particularly dialogue. There is a small plot omission but the addition of the time stamps helped since the narrative spans some sixteen years and wasn’t immediately obvious in the book. The acting was great and I was surprised that I found more emotion in the movie than the book. It’s a good adaptation and the small nuanced changes smoothed transitions.
Book Details:
Publisher: Highbridge Audio
Narrator: Scott Brick
Publication Date: April 1, 2014
Title Link(s):
Amazon-US | Amazon-UK | Kobo
The Author: GABRIELLE ZEVIN is the New York Times and internationally best-selling author of several critically acclaimed novels, including The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry and Young Jane Young. Her most recent novel is Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, a selection of the Tonight Show’s Fallon Book Club, the winner of the Goodreads Choice Award, a finalist for the Wingate Prize, and one of the best books of the year, according to the New York Times, the Washington Post, Time, Entertainment Weekly, the Atlantic, Amazon.com, Oprah Daily, Slate, NPR, and many others. The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry is now a feature film with a screenplay by Zevin. Her novels have been translated into forty languages. She lives in Los Angeles.
©2026 V Williams
Rosepoint Publishing 