The Book or the Movie—Which One First? Which One Was Better?

Book or Movie - which one first?

It’s the age-old conundrum—which first, the book or the movie? It appears I’ve managed to read several of these books prior to their release. Which ones have you read first? 

Wicked poster from Wikipedia
Wicked poster courtesy Wikipedia.

Haven’t we all been bombarded with the new movies, Christmas theme or not, out now riding on the heels of the book’s popularity? Lots of promos and book trailers, especially the big-budget Wicked by Gregory Maguire. Have you seen them? This one released in theaters on November 21st starring Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande. (Not one of the books I’ve read this year and not my thing.)

Of course, there is the wildly popular Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, originally released in 2012 (which I also didn’t read, not my thing), and my recent favorite, Where the Crawdads Sing by Delia Owens, released in 2022. The book was excellent–the movie very good.

Another to watch is The Housemaids (book by Freida McFadden) which will star Sydney Sweeney. Gees, I didn’t read that one either!) The release date for the movie is expected to be December 19, 2025. (I read The Housemaid’s Secret but not The Housemaid, so I’ll be interested in the original.)

I did, however, read several others and the ones listed as coming out soon read like a NY Times or USA Today bestseller list.

Margo's Got Money Troubles by Rufi ThorpeAnd surprise, surprise, another popular book, Margo’s Got Money Troubles by Rufi Thorpe, starring Elle Fanning has a release date TBA. I had a lot of fun and learned a lot with this book. Elle plays the daughter of a Hooters waitress and former pro-wrestler who’ll make it big on OnlyFans. Now’s your chance to get all the skinny. ;) I’m looking forward to this one. How about you?

The Women by Kristin HannahAlso in development for 2026 and 2027, The Nightingale and The Women by Kristin Hannah. Are you kidding? Read both, but I can’t wait to see The Women on screen! One of my very favorite books ever and was a Goodreads Choice Award Winner for Readers’ Favorite Historical Fiction of 2024 as well as an Editors’ Pick for Best Books of the Year 2024. Powerful, nostalgic, gripping. If you haven’t read it yet (fat chance), you must before the movie comes out.

Just a few others:

The Woman in Cabin 10 – Ruth Ware – released on Netflix starring Keira Knightley (started it–DNF).

The Husbands by Holly GramazioThe Husbands – Holly Gramazio – release date TBA – starring Juno Temple – FUN book! Recommended. The movie should be fun.

The Running Man – Stephen King – released on November 7 starring Glen Powell (but I don’t read Stephen King).

Of course, there were many more not listed here. How many of the above have you read? Look for audiobooks for these as well. Always a fast, easy way to get caught up on the latest of the books turned movie lists.

©2025 V Williams

#ThrowbackThursday

Rosepoint Reviews – August Recap – #Audiobooks #LiteraryFiction #LegalThriller #HistoricalFiction

Rosepoint Reviews-August Recap

Well, we certainly started out like it was August, but August petered out and started acting like Fall halfway into the month. Cool enough temps to warrant a sweater—it’s a cool wind that blows off those Great Lakes.

Still, some warm days and cool nights along with a couple gully washers produced an abundance of cucumbers and cantalopes, followed immediately by a surplus crop of cherry tomatoes. (I started adding cantaloupes to the cucumber juice—pretty good!) Not sure what happened to the Early Girl tomatoes, but hopefully we can dry enough cherry tomatoes to make several days of candy—so sweet and good. Also, in the crop this year, purple bell peppers and Japanese eggplant. I’ve started a second crop of peas and beans in the hope they’ll be ready to harvest prior to the end of the season—but realize I’m pushing my luck.

The August book pick at the Y Book Club was The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek. I’d read it years ago for a library book club in 2020 and opted to listen to the audiobook this time. I enjoyed both but this application was to refresh my memory for the Y book club.

Book Club at the Y - August

Once again, I love the insight brought to the novels by the participants. Most of us had never been aware of the “blue” people prior to reading the novel. While I voted 4.5 stars this time, I was surprised to see the average at four stars. Looking back at the vote for the same book by the earlier book club, was further surprised to see the average was the same. Four stars.

We reviewed thirteen books in August—half of those in audiobook form. The source of our books is our library, NetGalley, author and publisher requests. As always, the links on titles are to our reviews that include purchase information.

Rosepoint Reviews - August Recap

Wild Instinct by T Jefferson Parker (CE review)
False Witness by Phillip Margolin
The Other Side of Now by Paige Harbison (5 stars-audiobook)
Lowdown Road by Scott Von Doviak (CE review)
Great Big Beautiful Life by Emily Henry
The Arrangement by Kiersten Modglin (audiobook)
Her Cold Justice by Robert Dugoni
Endurance: Shackleton’s Incredible Voyage by Alfred Lansing (5 stars-audiobook)
The Proving Ground by Michael Connelly (5 stars)
Vera Wong’s Guide to Snooping by Jesse Q Sutanto (audiobook)
The River is Waiting by Wally Lamb (audiobook)
Two Audiobooks Mini-Reviews by Freida McFadden
The Housemaid’s Secret
The Boyfriend

 

Favorite Book of the Month

This is a tough one as I believe I set a record at three books with five stars in August, only one of those by a favorite author, the other two being new to me. I love Michael Connelly’s books, but really, have to give the nod this month to Alfred Lansing and his book Endurance. I’ve set the CE to reading Mark Twain by Ron Chernow. If you know anything about that masterful historical writer, you know his books are seldom under 700 pages. The CE will be reading it for awhile. (evil grin)

Favorite for August – Endurance by Alfred Lansing

 

Reading Challenges

My Reading Challenges page…I’m behind again and doubt I’ll catch up in September as we will be taking a short vacation.

The Goodreads landing page shows 132 of a goal of 150 or 88%. I suspect I’m doing well in the audiobook challenge as well, but can’t vouch for the NetGalley goal. May have to reassess those goals.

As always, it’s your visits and comments that keep me going and I appreciate them all. Kids are back in school (they don’t wait for Labor Day around here) and now’s the time we enjoy a short trip.

©2025 V Williams

AI graphic courtesy Gemini-Google