2024 Blog Post – Rosepoint Publishing

Rosepoint Reviews – December Recap – Ready to Start a New Year?

Rosepoint Reviews - December Recap

As usual, NWI can’t decide whether to stay temperate or freeze the trees. It’s been back and forth and now coming out of warmish temps will plunge back into frigid. It’s the sun I miss most.

We enjoyed a quiet Christmas and will do so again New Year’s Eve, the CE and I celebrating the new year with a four-ounce lobster tail each and watching the ball drop. Getting harder and harder for us old birds to stay awake that long though. Hope you had a safe New Year’s Eve and aren’t holding a throbbing head and looking for aspirin this morning, though I certainly remember doing so more than once back when…

I am definitely burning out, always so overwhelmed with everything going on I can’t keep up with either the reviews, social media, or you, my readers. Contemplating, and can’t decide, whether to change the format I’m currently using from WordPress (bored with it! but scared of messing everything up). And/or perhaps dropping another day of reviews since even the three per week appear to be more than I can handle. Also looking for another graphics website (free, of course) that I could play with other than Canva. I see the trend now is toward AI generated graphics. Mercy! As with WordPress, a free subscription is fairly limiting. Perhaps you use a great graphics design website that offers free software? I’d love your suggestions!

Using Goodreads to mine the opportunity for good audiobooks, our reads are also sourced at NetGalley, author and publisher requests, as well as your reviews and recommendations.

Despite the crunch of the holidays and our son moving, we managed thirteen reviews between us that included five audiobooks. These links on titles are to our reviews that include purchase or source information.

Rosepoint Reviews - December Recap

Lost Souls by Theo Baxter
The Waiting by Michael Connelly (audiobook)
Hold Strong by Robert Dugoni (CE review)
Deep Freeze by Michael C Grumley (audiobook)
Random in Death by J D Robb (CE review)
Still Me by Jojo Moyes
The Phoenix Crown by Kate Quinn and Janie Chang (audiobook)
Crime Scene by Jonathan Kellerman (audiobook)
Nothing Left of Me by Alex Walters (CE review)
The Sideways Life of Denny Voss by Holly Kennedy
You Never Know by Tom Selleck (audiobook)
What Is Wrong with You? By Paul Rudnick (CE review)
I’ll Have What She’s Having by Chelsea Handler

How did you do in the Goodreads Choice Awards for 2024? Of the fifteen categories, I had four make the final list and was gratified that The Women by Kristin Hannah, who I voted for in two categories, won for Historical Fiction. In the meantime, Goodreads has come out with the stats for our reading year for 2024 and I hope to have a post on it shortly.

Favorite Book of the Month

Once again, my vote goes to Kate Quinn and her co-author Janie Chang for their saga of strong women survivors of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, based on a number of historical tales including the real-life story of a woman still holding her place in the De Young Museum.

Favorite Book for December – The Phoenix Crown by Kate Quinn and Janie Chang

My Reading Challenges page…My Goodreads Challenge is at 134 making my goal of 130. I’m fairly sure I also made the Audiobook, Historical Fiction, and NetGalley Challenges, but until the dust settles around here, I can’t be certain. That will come later.

Welcome to my new subscribers. I hope all my readers, including you, are having a magical and love filled holiday season with family, food, and fun. Make it memorable!

Happy New Year!

Rosepoint Reviews – November Recap – Look Out, Here Comes the Snow and Ice

Rosepoint Reviews - November Recap

UGH! Not a fan of this time of year, the temps already plunging to the low teens with a “feels like” of 3 degrees. (Yeah, the Chicago wind.)

As I mentioned last month, in quick succession, we celebrated our daughter’s birthday, Halloween, and Thanksgiving, and if you celebrate Thanksgiving hope it was a good one and everyone is back home safe. All the cooking is getting to me and I’m beginning to check out the TV dinners in the grocery store. Problem with so many of those, of course, is all the stuff they put in the food, including Carrageenan (especially in pumpkin pie) and it really messes up my system. Of course, the CE loves his pumpkin pie and even homemade with evaporated milk contains the miserable stuff.

So, for me, Thanksgiving also kicks off the beginning of the Christmas holiday decorations. Usually have much of it done within a few days of Thanksgiving, but as our son is still here, I’m waiting a bit. It appears he’s got a house and will be moving out next week (it’s been a real struggle in a seller’s market). Of course, it’s also so cold I have no incentive to get the lights up outside either.

We celebrated Punkin’s first year with us. She’s beginning to blossom into a real dog, showing some personality. She’s doing better with potty time, adores her walks now with the CE and he is gradually allowing her more latitude, allowing her off-leash when they return to our yard. She takes in all the “messages” and then winds up to whiz into the house through the open door coming to a screeching stop and sliding on the laminate floor into her portable kennel.

Love those audiobooks at my local library, so many opportunities to listen to the books, otherwise, I’m busy morning to evening and don’t get that much reading time on my cell phone. Must admit they appear to be overtaking reading. Still, sources include NetGalley, as well as author and publisher requests and I’ve been mining Goodreads recommendations and blog reviews to find interesting books.

November reflected the blow to either reading or listening with only eleven titles. As always, links on titles are to our reviews that include purchase or source information.

Rosepoint Publishing - November Recap

Summit’s Edge by Sara Driscoll
Waking Up in Vegas by J E Rowney
The Art of Racing in the Rain by Garth Stein (audiobook)
A Slay Ride Together With You by Vicki Delany (audiobook)
Yesterday’s Paper: The Knocknashee Story by Jean Grainger
Ruthless Tide by Al Roker (audiobook)
Dead Men Wag No Tails by Sarah Fox (CE review)
The Last Thing He Told Me by Laura Dave (audiobook)
Omens by Kelley Armstrong (audiobook)
Sea of Death by Mark Nolan (buddy review with the CE)
The Grey Wolf by Louise Penny (audiobook)

Did you vote in the Goodreads Choice Awards for 2024? I wrote regarding the Choice Awards back in November. December 1 (that’s today!) is the last day to vote for your choice of the final round nominees. I see several of my reviewed novels made the final cut: Here One Moment by Liane Moriarty for Readers’ Favorite Fiction, The Women by Kristin Hannah for Favorite Historical Fiction and Favorite Audiobook, First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston for Favorite Mystery and Thriller, and Murder Road by Simone St James for Favorite Horror. Let me know if you found one of your favorites among the finalists.

Favorite Book of the Month

We posted three five-star reviews in November: Summit’s Edge, Yesterday’s Paper, and Sea of Death. Of course, each of these novels has radically different genres and Mark Nolan’s books are always a favorite. But then so are Jean Grainger’s and Sara Driscoll’s. The CE loves that Nolan’s books are fast-paced and action packed. I love that Grainger is pushing her boundaries with her historical novels and Driscoll’s books have my favorite dogs. Yeah, you’re right…it has to be:

Favorite for November – Summit’s Edge by Sara Driscoll

My Reading Challenges page…Reading Challenges page—always something that keeps me from catching up that page. My Goodreads Challenge is at 122 towards a goal of 130 for 94%. If we can manage our usual monthly number, should just make it.

Welcome to my new subscribers! And I always appreciate those of you who continue to monitor, read, and comment on my posts. Hope this recap finds you well and looking forward to the holidays!

Happy Autumn Sunday!

It’s Time to Vote in the Goodreads Choice Awards! #TuesdayBookBlog

My Goodreads Choice Awards for 2024

I’ve mentioned the Goodreads Choice Awards in previous years as it’s one of my favorite places to look for trending novels and authors, often finding my next book or audiobook.

I vote in each level from the opening round to the final round and some years score more winners than others. It’s fun to see how many of my reads, whether gleaned from Goodreads suggestions, publishers and authors, or NetGalley made it to the finals and, if so, where they came in. (Number 1?)

As of the prep for this post, there were already 2,736,392 votes cast in fifteen categories. Fiction, Historical Fiction, Mystery & Thriller, Romance, Romantasy, Fantasy, Science Fiction, Horror, Debut Nove, Audiobook, Young Adult Fantasy, Young Adult Fiction, Nonfiction, Memoir, History & Biography.

Romantasy? New last year? My favorite categories are Mystery & Thriller, Historical Fiction, Fiction, and Crime Fiction, but also read Humor, Memoir, Biography, Nonfiction, and Debut novels. Of course, the CE adds his own brand of reading usually of more masculine novels with action-adventure.

Up for consideration this year are eight of the books read in 2024 that landed on the list in the following categories: (Links are to my reviews which list sales info as well as the Goodreads link.)

Is one of these nominees yours?

Fiction

Here One Moment – Liane Moriarty* (audiobook)
Margo’s Got Money Troubles – Rufi Thorpe (audiobook)

Historical Fiction

The Women – Kristin Hannah*
The Frozen River – Ariel Lawhon (audiobook)

Mystery & Thriller

Darling Girls – Sally Hepworth* (audiobook)
The Heiress – Rachel Hawkins (audiobook)
First Lie Wins – Ashley Elston (audiobook-Reese’s Book Club selection)

Audiobook

The Women – Kristin Hannah*
Here One Moment – Liane Moriarty (audiobook)
Funny Story – Emily Henry (audiobook)
First Lie Wins – Ashley Elston (audiobook-Reese’s Book Club selection)

*My vote

(I’m rather surprised so many are from my audiobook selections.)

Last year, my Memoir & Autobiography vote went to Spare by Prince Harry, but surprised Britney Spears won for The Woman in Me (did you read that one? I read it but preferred Spare.) I did, however, pick the winner for the History & Biography category, The Wager. Gees, that was good and so glad it won!

There are 300 nominees this year across the 15 categories, but I swear a couple of those are new and a few categories were eliminated from previous years (poetry, middle grade and children’s, comic novels and graphics). The opening round of voting is between November 12 until November 24, so you still have time to make your voice heard.

Did one of your favorite books land in the nominees? Vote for it! The final round starts November 26, ends December 1. Winners are announced December 5.

So I have to ask:

How many of the above did you read?
In how many different categories do you participate?
Do you look for reading ideas from the Goodreads winners?
What is your source for 2025 trending books?
And, lastly—have you gone to any movies or viewed series based on one of your choices?

I’ve always appreciated Goodreads for the extensive resources they provide. I often check their New Releases section under “Browse” as well as Recommendations and crosscheck those against the offerings in NetGalley. If I cannot find the book in NetGalley, I check my local library and look for the audiobook first.

What is the book you are hoping to see listed in those nominees?

#TuesdayBookBlog

Rosepoint Reviews – October Recap – Welcome Holiday Season (or not)

Rosepoint Reviews-October Recap

October kicks off the end of the year for us, beginning with our daughter’s birthday in the middle of October and then Halloween of course, although we no longer celebrate the latter as much as we did when the kids were young, I still decorate. Seems like it then begins a mad dash to the end of the year and this year a presidential election here in the colonies—so glad to see the end of that!!

As much time spent in the spring setting up the yard, the gardens, and all things outdoors, it takes as much to clean it back up. Perhaps more so this year with tackling the veggie bed and cleaning up roots and dirt clods turned to cement. It was a disappointing year for a garden, veggie or flower.

Trying to recognize a full year with Punkin the Pom, I read several doggie genre books, adventure or service animals. A Pomeranian is meant to be a companion animal, of course, but she has no clue that’s her job. I am still finishing up a doggy theme book I’d hoped to include in October, the latest from Sara Driscoll, and ran out of time and will post that review in early November. As mentioned before…Punkin is still learning to be a dog. I guess eventually we’ll have to begin teaching her some commands. In the meantime, it’s sufficient to be working on housetraining. (Yeah, still.)

I continue to get books from NetGalley as well as author and publisher requests, and my local library, both ebooks and audiobooks. The review count for the month was fourteen, but I included both W Bruce Cameron’s novels in one post. As always, links on titles are to our reviews that include purchase or source information.

The Johnstown Flood by David McCullough (audiobook)
Here One Moment by Liane Moriarty (audiobook)
Echo by Tracy Clark
What Have You Done by Shari Lapena (audiobook)
Going Dark by George K Mehok (CE review)
Death by Jelly Beans by Susan Black
A Dog’s Courage and A Dog’s Promise by W Bruce Cameron (audiobook)
Late Checkout by Alan Orloff (CE review)
An Insignificant Case by Phillip Margolin
Margo’s Got Money Troubles by Rufi Thorpe (audiobook)
The More the Terrier by David Rosenfelt (audiobook)
Local Gone Missing by Fiona Barton (audiobook)
Death Comes in Threes by Michael Jecks (CE Review)

Favorite Book of the Month

The CE gave Going Dark by George K Mehok five stars but we both listened to The Johnstown Flood audiobook in our travels to and from Arkansas in September and loved it. The research, details, and characters so well-fleshed the reader cares what happens to them in the flood. I’m going with:

Favorite for October – The Johnstown Flood by David McCullough

My Reading Challenges page…Reading Challenges page—pretty much status quo. My Goodreads Challenge is at 110 towards a goal of 130 at 85%.

Thank you new subscribers—welcome! I always appreciate those of you who continue to monitor, read, and comment on my posts. Hope this recap finds you well and looking forward to the holidays!

Have a great weekend!

Rosepoint Reviews – September Recap – No More Tomatoes

Rosepoint Reviews-September Recap

Definitely flirting with inclement weather patterns when you wait until September in the Midwest to go on a road trip! That is becoming, however, our annual get-together time with our old Navy buddies from Texas. Last year we went to Hot Springs, Arkansas. Love those hot springs! This year it was Cherokee Village and Hardy, Arkansas. Why Arkansas? It’s approximately half way between the two of us—them coming from Texas.

The AirB&B was disappointing, but the area (seven lakes) was delightful and we lucked out with the weather, both coming and going and while we were there…home in time to miss the mess from Helene.

The Spring River area is absolutely lovely and the boys got in enough fishing to fill their hearts content—trout—a succulent feast. Regardless where we stay, we eat well! Lots of river and lake recreation from boating and fishing to swimming and rafting. We thought the fish were ours, the snake thought they were his. Kit and I were going to go kayaking until we saw the snapping turtles off the wharf where we stayed. And so much for swimming below the Mammoth Spring Dam (pic behind cover banner) when we got into a wrestling match for our trout left on the line in the water with a water moccasin. The snake got downright angry with me. (Pic cut from video.)

Returning home, I discovered the tomatoes had given up for the season, the garden looking very sad, with only a couple viable peppers remaining. Horrible garden year. Never did get my fill of fresh tomatoes and one or two paltry cucumbers didn’t make more than one or two salads. The squirrels wouldn’t leave my fresh greens alone either. I’ll try again next year.

Update on Punkin the Pomeranian: She’ll officially have been adopted a year on the eighth of October. She has now (1) bonded with the CE, (2) bonded with our son (who is still staying with us), (3) beginning to enjoy treats, (4) going on two-mile walks with the CE). She is still not tolerating my advance to her (runs back to her kennel) and although doing better, can’t say she is house trained yet. She is inconsistent with letting us know she needs to go out to do her business and we don’t always catch her. UGH. It’s good she’s cute.

I realized after I’d left that I should have left a note on the blog that I would be gone and apologize for all the stacked-up emails, notes, comments, and likes that were not acknowledged. I won’t make that mistake again. I tried to schedule some reviews but then was unable to connect with my little tablet and answer, respond, or post on social media.

Reduced activity on the blog in September, although I did get some reading done. I continue to get books from NetGalley as well as author and publisher requests, and my local library, both ebooks and audiobooks. Together we read or listened to eleven books. As always, links on titles are to our reviews that include purchase or source information.

Rosepoint Publishing - September Recap

Battle Annie by Trish MacEnultyBattle
You’ll Never Find Me by Allison Brennan (audiobook)
The Second Smartest Dog That Ever Lived by Will Pass (CE review)
Saving the Guilty by Liz Milliron
Fire and Bones by Kathy Reichs (audiobook)
Death Stake by Andrew Mayne (CE review)
Running on Empty by Karin Fitz Sanford
The Heiress by Rachel Hawkins (audiobook)
Color Me Dead by Teresa Trent
Darling Girls by Sally Hepworth (audiobook)
In Too Deep by Lee Child, Andrew Child (CE review)

Favorite Book of the Month

While I enjoyed that little surprise at the end of The Heiress, I gave Battle Annie five stars. The CE gave Death Stake five stars. Still, Darling Girls by Sally Hepworth kept me hanging on every word on the audiobook.

**Favorites for September – Darling Girls by Sally Hepworth**

My Reading Challenges page…obviously been too crazy around here lately but I think I might see light at the end of the tunnel now. My Goodreads Challenge is at 97 towards a goal of 130 at 75%. As for the rest, I’m still catching up from the vacation.

Thank you new subscribers—welcome! Appreciate those of you who continue to monitor, read, and comment on my posts. That’s what keeps me plodding forward!

#TuesdayBookBlog

Running on Empty by Karin Fitz Sanford #BookReview #TuesdayBookBlog

The Napa Valley of California draws thousands of luxury travelers annually sparking a multi-billion dollar impact in California.

A Wine County Cold Case

Book Blurb:

An unsolved murder. A Ponzi scheme. And a heist that has ex-FBI agent Anne McCormack racing throughout the wine country.

It’s been sixteen years since socialite Dinah Pardini’s body was found dumped in the backroads of Northern California’s wine country. But is her murder linked to the diabolical Ponzi scheme that now engulfs Santa Rosa, nearly bankrupting many Anne knows and loves? The ex-FBI agent-turned-estate liquidator certainly believes so and starts putting the clues together—which drives her into dangerous territory, both of the heart and body.

Anne will have to keep her wits about her if she plans on outracing thieves and on solving Dinah’s murder without becoming a victim herself, for dark forces are working against her at every turn and she’s running out of people to trust. Trust only in yourself, her uncle, a retired cop, once said. But to do that, Anne will have to forgive herself for a disastrous on-the-job judgment call that still haunts her, even as she hopes to bring criminals to justice and come out of this fever-paced adventure alive.

My Review:

Few areas of California more iconic than the Wine County of California. Beautiful rolling hills, fields of grapes and mustard, hot springs nearby. So it was easy to be drawn into this book, the cover, and the location.

Anne McCormack, an ex-FBI agent, runs an estate-sales business, along with her uncle Jack, retired law enforcement. The two have an extensive knowledge of police procedures and often assist the police with cold cases. They are doing that when they are led into this particular case, a question of murder, interesting connection.

Unfortunately, the recent victim had initialed a Ponzi scheme which bilked many friends, family, and anyone connected out of millions of dollars. He wasn’t exactly loved and there was no shortage of people who thought he got what he deserved.

Of course, I was looking for fun stuff about the wine country (would have appreciated more), but was interested in the main characters, who I found engaging including the dog, a golden retriever named Trailer.

The Ponzi tale is complex, the bad guys corrupt, the good guys (and gals) sincere but not infallible. Anne is well developed and I enjoyed reading about her skills in the estate sales business. Twists and turns lead to ever-widening clues and the ending zinger was fun.

Ordinary people doing their job the best they can while going about their lives. Believable characters, well-plotted and paced. I’ll be interested in another wine country installment.

I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the author and publisher through @NetGalley that in no way influenced this review. These are my honest thoughts.

Rosepoint Rating: Four Stars

Book Details:

Genre: Heist Crime, Financial Thrillers
Publisher: Level Best Books
ASIN: B0CYFRW77J
Print Length: 328 pages
Publication Date: May 7, 2024
Source: Publisher and NetGalley

Title Link(s):

Amazon-US | Amazon-UK | Barnes & Noble | Kobo

The Author: Karin Fitz Sanford, a former advertising copywriter, was born in New York but grew up in Northern California’s Wine Country, the setting for her WINE COUNTRY COLD CASE series. Having run her own award-winning ad agency for over twenty-five years, she now devotes herself full time to writing. She lives in Northern California with her husband.

#TuesdayBookBlog

Rosepoint Reviews – August Recap – Books, Covid, and Dogs

Rosepoint Reviews-August Recap

Just when we had a stretch of mild weather, beautiful temps for everything I wanted to do outside, I went grocery shopping. A few days later, I came down with Covid—whichever variety is currently going around, I guess, and a few days after that, the CE came down with it. Here we’ve gotten all through ’20, ’21, ’22, and ’23, then got caught. Definitely laid me low for two weeks and then another two weeks still lacking any energy and short on stamina. Fortunately, our son didn’t catch it for another few days, so he was able to see we had something to eat. Well, I covered that saga in my reviews posted both the eleventh and the thirteenth.

Also fortunate that our son was able to double down and take care of his own dog, a mini-Aussie-Jack Russell and ours as well. Punkin is always careful to make sure Cooper remembers the house is hers, but Cooper made herself at home early on. Cooper (Remember the puppy?) It is a year last August our daughter surprised us with her. I was missing Frosty so much—but more than that—the joy and companionship a dog brings to the household. Cooper grew into approximately 35 lbs of exuberant and energetic watch dog and indefatigable ball retriever. She tries so hard to talk, but I haven’t quite understood a word yet.

So obviously, not a lot of activity on the blog in August, although I did get some reading done. I’m still getting books from NetGalley as well as author and publisher requests, and my local library. Two novels were given a DNF this month (not included in the list below), one from the CE and one from myself and both at just about 25%. Just didn’t click with either of us, totally unusual. As always, links on titles are to our reviews that include purchase or source information.

Rosepoint Reviews - August Recap

The Blind Devotion of Imogene by David Putnam
On Wahoo Reef by Tim W Jackson
The Broken Truth by Reavis Wortham (CE review)
Zephyr Trails by Nicki Ehrlich
Appalachian Song by Michelle Shocklee
Echoes of Memory by Sara Driscoll (audiobook)
Big Love and War Horse by Shallen Anne Chitwood
Hillbilly Elegy by J D Vance (audiobook)
Dog Day Afternoon by David Rosenfelt (audiobook)

Favorite Book of the Month

I really enjoyed Hillbilly Elegy but waffled on five stars. The CE gave The Broken Truth five stars, so I must bow to his choice.

**Favorites for August – The Broken Truth by Reavis Wortham**

My Reading Challenges page…

Reading Challenges page—at this point woefully behind schedule and forced to reduce the Goodreads Challenge from 150 to 130. The CE is reducing his reading and reviewing and I still owe two reviews to Goodreads.

Love my new subscribers—welcome! Thank you to those of you who continue to monitor, read, and comment on my posts. I appreciate you!

Enjoy Your Sunday

Netflix Movie Hillbilly Elegy vs #audiobook by J D Vance #EthnicStudies

Introduction

With my recent discovery of both the audiobook at my local library and the movie on Netflix (not sure for how much longer), I thought it a good time to post another Movie vs Book article. Nothing here advocating any candidate. That is not my intention. It’s a look at the book and the Ron Howard film the book generated.

The Movie

A Ron Howard film directed and produced (with partners), Howard put together a powerful cast of actors. Once again, a sharp divide between critics opinions and audience reviews. Some said it veered too far off the novel—I felt it followed fairly close. There are always little deviations, but the film did not lose the book’s essence. For his efforts, he won the Golden Raspberry Award. (really?!)

Glenn Close plays the grandmother, Mamaw, who turned in a remarkable performance using facial expressions and her eyes to cement the tension of the scene. She affected the walk of a long-suffering grandmother doing the best she could. One of the five most nominated actresses for an Oscar; lost Best Supporting Actress that year, also nominated for several other awards including the Golden Globe.

(“I’ll cancel your birth certificate!”)

Amy Adams, given the difficult role of JDs mother, also continues to stretch her acting chops, turning in a compelling performance as Bev Vance. Hers was considered the leading role. Again, though often thought a strong contender, has been denied either the nomination or the win come Oscar time. There is some controversy whether or not this should have been her turn—apparently not.

Gabriel Basso, who plays the adult J D Vance, would have been a Navy Seal had he not experienced a torn labrum. Beginning as a child actor, he has secured three nominations and two wins. Easily recognizable now for his latest action thriller series, also on Netflix, The Night Agent, he’s been active in both film and television.

I’m a little puzzled over the controversy this film generated. Was it just too honest? Reviews and opinions are all over the place. Everyone comes from a different experience and applying the message from the film might generate a range of conflicting judgments. And that’s okay. We’re all entitled.

The Book

First time I’ve noticed the Amazon ratings 106,821 with 4.4 stars and a 3.9 on Goodreads with 426,652 ratings in the heading.

#1 Best Seller in Sociology

A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis

My Thoughts

Of course, when he was nominated the VP candidate, I had to look for information on him and found this memoir. I’m a fan of books about the Appalachian area and memoirs anyway. When I discovered it among the audiobooks at my local library, I jumped on it.

To say I was a bit surprised would be an understatement. It’s a raw, no holds barred and very graphic account of his childhood to adulthood. (While my dad’s side hailed from Missouri, I couldn’t help but find so many similarities in the description of family life, it was scary. Apparently, a common trait among the folk from those eastern hills.)

Largely raised by his grandmother, it was her philosophy of life that instilled a fierce devotion and loyalty to family. Whether now well Yale educated or not, ex-Marine or not, a life in two worlds, it would appear that it is his Appalachian bearing that still wields the powerful hammer.

Many of his conservative ideas are controversial but he comes from a different universe than most of his congressional billionaire-building cohorts. If he appears to exhibit some pride by making it from extreme poverty, drug use, and alcohol to his station today, perhaps he has a right. (I never forgot where I came from and thinking that this was as good as it was going to get was a plateau I never overcame. Still, I’ve been a lucky one.)

And so was he. Although his message may be one of taking responsibility for oneself—and stop the blame game—he managed to receive some lucky breaks. Supportive family, a Yale education, the right mentors. He tends to some deep introspection and certainly makes a lot of astute observations, offering some stats and info to back his theories and analyses of how or why the country got so divided.

Thought-provoking, heart-pounding narrative that describes the lows, the loss of hope, and then the swing to achievement and triumph.

Curious? It’s definitely worth a listen.

Audiobook (Blurb)

Winner, 2017 APA Audie Awards – Nonfiction

From a former marine and Yale Law School graduate, a powerful account of growing up in a poor Rust Belt town that offers a broader, probing look at the struggles of America’s white working class.

Hillbilly Elegy is a passionate and personal analysis of a culture in crisis – that of white working-class Americans. The decline of this group, a demographic of our country that has been slowly disintegrating over 40 years, has been reported on with growing frequency and alarm but has never before been written about as searingly from the inside. J. D. Vance tells the true story of what a social, regional, and class decline feels like when you were born with it hung around your neck.

The Vance family story begins hopefully in postwar America. J. D.’s grandparents were “dirt poor and in love” and moved north from Kentucky’s Appalachia region to Ohio in the hopes of escaping the dreadful poverty around them. They raised a middle-class family, and eventually their grandchild (the author) would graduate from Yale Law School, a conventional marker of their success in achieving generational upward mobility.

But as the family saga of Hillbilly Elegy plays out, we learn that this is only the short, superficial version. Vance’s grandparents, his aunt, his uncle, his sister, and most of all his mother struggled profoundly with the demands of their new middle-class life and were never able to fully escape the legacy of abuse, alcoholism, poverty, and trauma so characteristic of their part of America. Vance piercingly shows how he himself still carries around the demons of their chaotic family history.

A deeply moving memoir with its share of humor and vividly colorful figures, Hillbilly Elegy is the story of how upward mobility really feels. And it is an urgent and troubling meditation on the loss of the American dream for a large segment of this country.

The Author

J. D. Vance grew up in the Rust Belt city of Middletown, Ohio, and the Appalachian town of Jackson, Kentucky. He enlisted in the Marine Corps after high school and served in Iraq. A graduate of Ohio State University and Yale Law School, he was elected to the United States Senate representing Ohio in 2022. In 2024, he became the Republican nominee for Vice President. Vance lives in Columbus, Ohio, with his family.

Book Details

Genre: Ethnic Studies, Poverty, Sociology
Publisher: HarperAudio
ASIN: B01EM4ZJBO
Listening Length: 6 hrs 49 mins
Narrator: J. D. Vance
Audible Release: June 28, 2016
Source: Local Library (Audiobook Selections)
Title Link: Hillbilly Elegy [Amazon]

Goodreads Choice Award

Nominee for Best Memoir & Autobiography (2016)

Overall Impression

I greatly enjoyed the audiobook, narrated by the author, his scrapping childhood enough to break or harden any but the most hardy individual. I listened with interest to his assessment of the divide that exists in the country, critical of many government practices. His is an honest voice I’m sure heard with a jaundiced ear—I doubt he has a problem suppressing his thoughts.

Conclusion

Both the film and the audiobook (and I’d recommend the audiobook) are worth the time for the read and/or watch.

The actors turn in a credible performance—I was especially impressed with Glenn Close—not usually one of my favorites. Amy Adams sold her role of a mother whose lifestyle cemented the inability to care for her children. The critics hated the flick. Audience reviews were more generous. (And by the way, those iconic glasses worn by Glenn Close were Mamaws own glasses, loaned to the actress for her part.)

Did the movie go overboard with the castigation of the Appalachian people in general? Possibly. It’s a searing indictment of the predicament of the poor of the region. In the blame game—who is responsible? A government turning a blind eye? The people themselves? Is Vance pushing the edict, “If I got out, so can you?” Yeah, maybe, or it may be more, “I got out and look at me now!” Hoorah!

In any case, if you can separate the politics and just enjoy the story, either the book or the movie is gripping and powerful entertainment and I’d recommend both.

#TuesdayBookBlog